Sen. McCain’s daughter, Meghan, writes in support for “A Gayer GOP“… She makes very good points:
The Log Cabin Republicans’ mission “is to work within the Republican Party to advocate equal rights for all Americans, including gays and lesbians.” The group is centered on core Republican values, such as limited government, individual liberty and responsibility, an economy based in free markets, and a strong national defense. And in the spirit of the GOP’s founding beliefs—personal freedom and liberty—they are dedicated to securing full equality for gays and lesbians in America to create a stronger, larger, and more-unified GOP.What I found most interesting about the Log Cabin Republicans is where and when they got their start: in California, during the late ’70s. At the time, much of the progress made in securing equal rights for gays was drawing a backlash. A successful movement to overturn antidiscrimination laws in Dade County, Florida, was led by singer Anita Bryant. States like Arkansas and Oklahoma prohibited gays from teaching jobs. And a California Republican state senator suggested a proposition for voters to keep gays and lesbians from teaching in public schools. (At one point, the initiative was leading in polls with more than 60 percent of voters supporting it.) In the end, voters rejected the proposition in November 1978, by a margin of more than a million votes. While several prominent Democrats and Republicans rallied to secure its defeat, one Republican in particular helped turn the tide—former California Governor Ronald Wilson Reagan.
She’s absolutely correct about those Republican values. Also, bonus on bringing up the tidbit about Reagan’s fight for gay rights. But President Bush’s eight years have brought about an unexpected split among the GOP: the “social conservatives” no longer identifying with the “political conservatives,” the Republican Party we know today. And that’s one of the reasons Meghan’s father lost to Barack Obama. Disillusioned conservatives punished the GOP by not voting or worse yet, voting for Obama.
Perhaps the Republican’s message on gay issues isn’t clear enough? The anti-gay backslash stemmed primarily from gay activists’ agenda of redefining marriage on a national level. Marriage is an institution established way prior to the gay rights movement. Most Americans don’t care what adults do in their own homes and in their own times, but most Americans aren’t ready to accept a family with two “married” daddies or mommies. More importantly, gays today enjoy the same civil liberties as everyone else. It’s left to the states to determine how they want to treat marriage and that’s just fine. The Constitution says nothing about the federal government defining marriage, so it’s reasonable that this decision is left to the state legislatures.
I applaud Ms. McCain’s effort in turning the GOP into a more gay-friendly political party, but should that be the focus of party leaders? There is comfort in knowing about the existence of the Log Cabin Republicans and gay conservatives. After all, we hardly ever hear about pro-life liberals. Doesn’t that clearly illustrate the Republican Party’s wider acceptance? Let’s hope her efforts do not end up being a distraction to the core GOP agenda.
